Showing posts with label Brockton. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Brockton. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Proposed Judgement on Custody and Parenting Plan 2012



COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
Plymouth/Brockton, SS                                                                  PROBATE COURT
                                                                                          DOCKET NO.: 06D0566-DV1
**************************
LAURA BONETZKY-JOSEPH, Plaintiff
Vs
MARLON JOSEPH, Defendant
**************************
LAURA BONETZKY-JOSEPH’S PROPOSED JUDGMENT ON CUSTODY AND PARENTING PLAN

RELATED ISSUES
1.       CUSTODY: 
a.       Mother shall have full legal and physical custody of the children. The parenting time with the children is set forth below. The Father shall cooperate as to any updates Mother may need to the medical care, education, moral and religious development, and welfare, regarding the children.  The school system shall be Hull Public School without prejudice. Since the children were recently moved to an entirely new school district in Bridgewater, MA, they have not yet developed roots there so this shall not be an issue. The oldest daughter, Alexandria is age 14 and currently in grade 9. The middle daughter, Shannon, is age 11and in grade 6. The youngest daughter, Kelly, is age 8 and in grade 3.
b.      Father shall be remanded for incarceration for 60days without parole.

2.      NON-HOLIDAY PARENTING SCHEDULE:   
a.       The Mother shall have primary physical custody of the children and Father shall receive visitation. Father shall cooperate with Mother in regards to visitation and abide by the court’s orders or he shall forfeit his rights to any visitation. Father shall have supervised visitation on Wednesdays from 4-6pm in Hull. Father shall pick up the children at the Hull Police Department and shall return the children there too. Father shall also have supervised visitations every other Saturday from 10am-6pm with the pickup and drop off at the Hull Police Station beginning the second Saturday after the Court’s rulings. After six months of successful uninterrupted visitation by Father, with a review by the court and report submitted to this court, Father shall have overnight visitation with the children every other weekend.  At that time, if approved by the court, Father shall pick up the children every other weekend from Saturday at 9am at the Hull Police Department and Mother shall pick up the children at the Plymouth Police station on Sunday at 6pm.  Father shall pay for all the costs associated to the visitations.
b.      Father shall not discuss, probe, or interrogate the children in regards to their mother or this case. If Father fails to do so, Father will lose visitation rights with his children.
c.       The Mother shall provide a loving, caring and supportive environment for the children that is conducive to the emotional development of the children.

3.      ADDITIONAL TIME – SPECIAL EVENTS:
a.       The Father shall have additional time with the children at all other reasonable times with reasonable notice via email or txt message to Mother (no less than 48 hours in advance) or by agreement. This shall only take affect once Father has demonstrated his abilities to restrain himself from emotionally, mentally, or physically abusing the children and after the Court approves after his six month probation period of supervised visitation.
b.      TRANSPORTATION: Starting immediately, Father shall pick up and drop off the children for the first six months at the Hull Police Department. Once the Court has approved the unspervision, and Father has complied with the visitation agreement 100% without incident, the parties shall equally share the responsibility of picking up and dropping off the children as follows: Father shall pick up the children every other weekend from Saturday at 9am at the Hull Police Department and Mother shall pick up the children at the Plymouth Police station on Sunday at 6pm. Father shall not have any verbal contact with Mother during transition and shall park in an area that is safe for the children to transfer to the other parent.  Father shall not park in a way that will place the safety of Mother and/or the children in jeopardy. Father shall remain in the car at all times. Mother will escort the children if necessary.
c.       Change Parenting Schedule: The parenting schedule set forth below represents a general standard.  The Court acknowledges that due to the parties’ present and potential work schedule, it may be necessary from time to time for the parties to vary the schedule set forth below. The parties need to be flexible.  In event a request is made to vary day s or times of visits, barring emergencies, the requesting party shall attempt to give the other reasonable advance notice which shall in any event be no less than three days written notice via email or text message. Father shall not abuse this privilege or he shall lose his abilities to make temporary changes. The Court also acknowledges Father repeated patterns of neglecting and abusing such privileges in the past and shall lose all visitation rights if he attempts to abuse this privilege.
d.      Clothing, Homework, etc: Father shall turn over immediately all the children’s personal belongings including all clothing, toys, books, personal care items, or anything the children deem “theirs”. Father shall not hinder the transition or interfere with the children’s right to gather their belongings. If Father fails to comply, the Plymouth Police will intervene on Mother’s behalf to ensure a smooth transition. Mother shall have the children adequately prepared and reasonably ready with adequate clothing, homework, supplies, etc for all parenting time with Father, which shall be returned to Mother after their parenting time.
e.        Emergency Authorization:  In the event of any illness, injury, or non-routine medical treatment of a child, Mother will have the sole authority to consent to medical treatment for a child. Father shall make immediate and prompt efforts to notify Mother of any medical concerns or illness.
f.       Communications About Illness, Injury or Emergency:  In the event of any illness, injury, or non-routine medical treatment of a child, Mother shall have the sole right to consent to emergency medical treatment for a child.  Father shall immediately make every effort to promptly notify Mother of the illness, injury, or non-routine treatment. In the event that the child is at the hospital or doctor’s office and/or while a child is being treated, Mother shall have the right to be with the child at all times regardless of the parenting schedule set forth below.
g.      Removal of children:  Neither parent shall permanently remove the children out of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts without the other parent’s express written approval or the approval of the Massachusetts Courts obtained pursuant to MGL c. 208, sec 30.  However, in the event Father, by act of his own, loses visitation with the children, Mother will not have to seek the permission neither from Father nor from the Court.
h.      Access to Information:
                                                              i.      Records and individuals.  Each party shall have the right after email written notice, without order of the Court, to review and have direct access to all educational, medical and dental records of the children. Any copies receive by either parent shall be mailed to the other parent immediately. If the parent who obtains copies and fails to do so will be required to pay for any out of pocket expenses not limited to legal fees and court fees to compel the other parent to forward copies. Father shall have the right with permission of Mother or the Court, to consult and meet with individuals, experts, and/or professionals who provide services to the children, including those at any educational institution the children are attending. If Father creates problems, becomes abusive, or employs tactics to harm Mother or the children, Father shall automatically lose those rights.  Mother shall make all decisions in regards to the counseling and therapy needs of the children without Father’s consent. Mother shall make sole decisions in the children’s every day care including setting appointments and/or cancellations as necessary without obstructions from Father.
                                                            ii.      Each party shall have open access to the children’s records/documents, and agree to share with each other upon request important records/documents, including but not limited to the following:  education, therapy, additional services, advocates, medical records, birth certificates, passports, vaccination documentations, and social security cards.
i.        General Provisions:  Neither party shall attempt not condone any attempt to estrange the children from the other parent, or to injure or impede the respect or affection of the children for the other parent.  Both parties shall at all times encourage and foster in the children respect and affection for both parents outside the absence of abuse or maltreatment. Neither parent shall denigrate the other parent, alienate the other parent from the children, or in any manner to injure or interfere with the relationship between the other parent and the children outside the absence of abuse, maltreatment, or abuse protection order. Neither parent shall discuss the divorce or court proceedings (except in counseling) or allow others to discuss the divorce case or custody in front of the children.  Neither party shall use or allow profanity in front of the children.

4.      Traveling Outside the Commonwealth: The Father shall have the right to remove the children from the Commonwealth of Massachusetts for trips and vacations which are temporary in nature (no more than 72 hours), to the neighboring states, but shall notify the other in writing by email or text messaging in advance of no less than 14 days notice of such trips and vacations and advise where the children will be and the phone number of the location to where the children can be reached. The Mother shall have the right to remove the children from the Commonwealth of Massachusetts for trips and vacations which are temporary in nature (no more than 72 hours), but shall notify the other in writing by email or text messaging in advance of no less than 14 days notice of such trips and vacations and advise where the children will be and the phone number of the location to where the children can be reached. Father shall not be allowed to remove the children to travel outside the New England states or travel abroad without permission from Mother and as long as there is no question of the children’s safety. If permission is granted and there is no question pertaining to the children’s safety, Father shall provide Mother all flight times, flight numbers, plane destinations, itineraries, within a minimum of 30 days written notice and approval before trip.

5.      HOLIDAY AND VACATION SCHEDULE
a.       The provisions for holiday and vacation visitation, as set forth in this paragraph, will supersede the provisions regarding parenting times set forth.  Specifically, when there is a holiday which is described in this Agreement, the parties shall follow the holiday schedule and interrupt the regular non-holiday schedule. This schedule only takes place upon Father’s successful completion of the probationary period for visitations as stated previously.
b.      Easter Sunday. Unless the parties otherwise agree or work schedules do not permit, the children shall spend Easter Sunday with Mother in 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016,  and 2017 to make up for lost time spent children have not spent with Mother in 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, and 2012. Afterwards, the children shall be with Father on even years beginning in 2018 and with Mother on odd years. Easter Sunday shall be defined as Sunday at 8:00am until 8:00pm
c.       Memorial Day: Commencing in 2012 and each year thereafter, unless the parties agree otherwise or the parties work schedule does not permit, the children shall spend Memorial Day with the Mother as well as in 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2016  to make up for lost time spent children have not spent with Mother in 2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011. Afterwards, the children shall be with Father on odd years beginning in 2017 and with Mother on even years. Memorial Day shall be from 9:00am to 7:00pm
d.      4th of July:  Commencing in 2012 and each year thereafter, unless the parties agree otherwise or the parties work schedule does not permit, the children shall spend 4th of July with the Mother as well as in 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2016, 2017 to make up for lost time spent children have not spent with Mother in 2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011.  Afterwards, the children shall be with Father on even years beginning in 2018 and with Mother on odd years. 4th of July shall be from 9:00am until July 5th dropping the children off at the residence in accordance to the summer visitation schedule by approximately 7:00pm.
e.       Columbus Day Weekend: Commencing in 2012 and each year thereafter, unless the parties agree otherwise or the parties work schedule does not permit, the children shall spend Columbus Day Weekend with the Mother as well as in 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2016, 2017 to make up for lost time spent children have not spent with Mother in 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011.  Afterwards, the children shall be with Father on even years beginning in 2018 and with Mother on odd years. Columbus Day Weekend shall be defined as commencing at 4:30pm on Friday before Columbus Day until Monday at 7:30pm.
f.       Thanksgiving Holiday: Commencing in 2012 and each year thereafter, unless the parties agree otherwise or the parties work schedule does not permit, the children shall spend Thanksgiving with the Mother as well as in 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2016, 2017, and 2018 to make up for lost time spent children have not spent with Mother in 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011.  Afterwards, the children shall be with Father on odd years beginning in 2019 and with Mother on even years. Thanksgiving holiday shall be defined as commencing from after school on the last day of classes before Thanksgiving until Sunday at 7:30pm.
g.      Thanksgiving Holiday: Commencing in 2012 and each year thereafter, unless the parties agree otherwise or the parties work schedule does not permit, the children shall spend Thanksgiving with the Mother as well as in 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2016, 2017, and 2018 to make up for lost time spent children have not spent with Mother in 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011.  Afterwards, the children shall be with Father on odd years beginning in 2019 and with Mother on even years. Thanksgiving holiday shall be defined as commencing from after school on the last day of classes before Thanksgiving until Sunday at 7:30pm.
h.      Christmas Holiday: Commencing in 2012 and each year thereafter, unless the parties agree otherwise or the parties work schedule does not permit, the children shall spend the Christmas Holiday with the Mother as well as in 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2016, and 2017, to make up for lost time spent children have not spent with Mother in 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011.  Afterwards, the children shall be with Father on even years beginning in 2018 from noon on Christmas Day, December 25th through January 1st at noon and with Mother on odd years. 

6.      VACATIONS
a.      February and April Vacations:  The parties shall rotate have the children for February Vacation and April Vacations with the Father taking February on all even years and Mother taking April on all even years.  The week is defined as Monday from 9:00am through Friday at 7:30pm. This schedule shall commence in 2018 to make up for lost time spent children have not spent with Mother in 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011.
b.      Summer School Vacation:
                                                              i.      The parties shall be entitled to have the children for two, non-consecutive weeks during the children’s summer school vacation. The week shall be defined as Monday at 8:00am through Friday at 7:30pm
                                                            ii.       In order to timely schedule the children’s summer school vacation schedule, including camps and activities, Father shall notify Mother no later than March 30th in writing to which two weeks he shall select commencing in 2013. Father shall not select a summer school vacation period which would occur during a holiday in which the Mother is scheduled to be with the children. Father shall have this right as long as there are no concerns or issues concerns abuse or maltreatment by Father and as long as Father has successfully completed the probationary visitation schedule without complication or incident. Otherwise, Father will forfeit this right.

7.      MOTHER’S/FATHER’S DAY:  The children shall always be with their Mother for Mother’s Day commencing in 2012 and shall always be with the Father for Father’s Day commencing in 2013. In 2012, the children shall spend Father’s Day with their maternal grandfather to make up for lost time obstructed by Father. These days shall be defined as Saturday at 6:00pm, the day before Mother’s Day or Father’s Day until Sunday at 7:00pm.

8.      LIFE CYCLE EVENTS:  It is in the children’s best interest to attend life cycle events, such as weddings, graduations, funerals, religious celebrations, and other major family functions.  Therefore, the parties agree to cooperate with each other in effectuating this provision with each family and household. If such event occurs during Father’s probationary visitation schedule, Father shall pay all expenses for the children and mother so Mother may ensure the safety and well being of her children. Mother will require the names of two competent adults with whom she feels confident the children will remain safe to escort the children during this event or be supervised by a Court Appointed Supervisor. If the event is out of the country, Father will need Mother’s permission to remove the children from the country to ensure the children will return safe and unharmed.

9.      TELEPHONE CALLS BETWEEN PARENTS AND CHILDREN: Each parent shall have the right to telephone the children at all reasonable times in the evening when the children are with the other parent. The parent with whom the children are then residing shall make the children reasonably available for a telephone call from the other parent on a daily basis (absent special circumstances such as illness, events outside the home, etc.)  The children shall be permitted to call the parent with whom they are not then residing at all reasonable times. To avoid a repeat of past problems, Father shall furnish the each of the children a working cell phone and pay all costs associated with the phone so they may maintain unhampered contact with the other parent and relatives.  The phone will travel back and forth with the child.  The parents shall not monitor, record, or restrict the children’s telephone calls to the other parent.  They shall have unrestricted time to speak with the other parent.

10.  MANDATORY THERAPY: 
a.       The children shall immediately be engaged in weekly therapy as determined by Mother. This shall be for a period for no less than one year or fifty-two (52) sessions to be determined by the children’s therapist after interviews with the children and parents.  The Father shall pay for any and all costs associated with therapy. Any adjustment to the schedules for the children shall be made accordingly as determined by the children’s therapist and Mother.
b.      The Father shall not delay of interfere with the maintenance or selection of the children’s therapist. Father shall not use an undisclosed named counselor who may have been selected without prior notification prior to trial in October 2011 or without Mother’s consent. Therapy will start with the children forthwith as soon as the therapist’s schedule permits.

11.  PARENTING TIME: 
a.       Once Father’s probationary visitation has been successfully completed, the parties shall have the right and responsibility to see and take the children individually and/or collectively as the parent time requirements of the children may change.  Both parties shall give the other reasonable notice, 48hours in advance or by agreement of any reasonable changes. If Father abuses this privilege, his rights to this section will be terminated and he will reimburse Mother any out of pocket expenses for such abuse.
b.      During all parenting time, Father shall be responsible to assure that the children attend all regularly scheduled activities, appointments, and religious obligations. Mother shall provide Father with any communication received from those activities, appointments, etc.  The parties shall use email and text message to keep the other informed of all activities, changes etc. In the event of an emergency, each will have telephone contact directly with the other about the children or life cycle events (i.e. death, funerals, etc) only. Neither Father, Step-Mother (Andrea Joseph) nor Mother shall attempt or condone any attempt to estrange the children from the other or to injure or impede the respect or affection of the children for the other, but on the contrary shall at all times encourage and foster in the children respect and affection for both parents. No plans shall be made with the children that supersede the parenting schedule unless otherwise noted in this order.  All discussions shall be between the Mother and Father in advance of any detailed discussion with the children.  Neither party shall condone or approve of overriding of the other’s parenting times and authority of their time with the children of through the children. Any missed parenting time due to illness or Mother, will be made up within 60 days. If Father misses parenting time for any reason, he shall not be allowed to make up the time. The Step-Mother, identified as Andrea Joseph, shall also abide by the terms of this agreement.
c.       The Mother owns a therapy dog used for healing known as “Ava”. Father shall not discourage or prevent the children’s relationship with the family dog in any way, and shall encourage the relationship.

12.  MEDICAL INSURANCE:  The Father shall maintain a family medical and dental plan to also include psychotherapy and eye care for the children.  If Father changes employers who have a public plan, the Father shall provide written notice to the Mother and provide medical insurance to the Mother pursuant to M.G.L. c.175 Sec 110(i) regardless of remarriage by the Father. If Father cannot provide health insurance for the children, the Mother will be required to do so if available to her and Father will reimburse Mother for any out of pocket expenses.  The Father shall pay any co-payments for the children and non-covered expenses as stated above.

13.  CHILD SUPPORT / ALIMONY:  The Father shall pay Mother a weekly child support based on the current child support guidelines.  Father shall produce the tax returns for 2010 and 2011 to determine the rates within 2 weeks of this judgment. ALIMONY? Am I entitled based on the fact John defrauded the Divorce decree by trying to force Mother to sign away her father’s rights to any criminal wrong doing of the monies stolen?


14.  EMANCIPATION; Child support, if applicable, shall continue until the emancipation of the children at which time payment shall cease.  Emancipation shall be deemed on any of the following events: (a) marriage of the child; (b) permanent residence away from the residence of the Mother, this shall not include temporary residence for school, college, or summer camp or with the Father; (c) death; (d) entry into the armed forces, peace corps or the like; (e) graduation from high school and not principally dependent on the parent until age 21, however, if the child is then admitted to college and enrolled in full-time academic courses, payment shall continue for so long as the child is a full-time student, but not later than age 25, of (f) as further defined, including all current and future amendments under M.G.L. Chapter 208, Section 28 as amended.
15.  TAXES: 
a.       The Father shall be entitles to claim two of the children as dependency exemption on his Federal and State Income tax returns for all the years as long as father has been fully compliant with all child support, medical expenditures, and any other financial obligations.
b.      Father shall immediately turn over a copy of his 2006 and 2007 federal and state tax returns and immediately (within 7 days) reimburse Mother half of the returns plus (6) six percent interest as a penalty for failing to abide the Divorce agreement. 

16.  EXTRA-CURRICULAR ACTIVITES:  Bother parties shall pay one half of all extra-curricular activities of the children including, but not limited to school expenses, sports, music, camps, field trips, proms, and school functions. These expenses shall not exceed $2,000.00 per child, per year.  No child shall be enrolled in any event or program exceeding $200.00 without prior written notification to the other parent, said notification not to be unreasonably withheld. If the extra-curricular activity is booked during Father’s parenting time, he shall attend or take the child to the activity or have adjustment to the weekly parenting schedule but only after all reasonable attempts to keep the schedule and/or only after a recommendation by the children’s therapist.

17.  REGARDING CONTEMPT ISSUES:
a.       2006 and 2007 Taxes Returns:   Father shall immediately turn over a copy of his 2006 and 2007 federal and state tax returns and immediately (within 7 days)  reimburse Mother half of the returns plus (6) six percent interest as a penalty for failing to abide the Divorce agreement. 
b.      Visitation interference:  Father shall be sanctioned $100 per visit missed with mother and Mother shall have make-up time as laid out previously in this order.  Father shall also pay for all of Mother’s current legal fees associated with this custody case from March 2009 to the date of this order for a total of $125,000. Father shall also be remanded into custody for each day Father did not bring the children to visitation with Mother as court ordered for a maximum of six months.
c.       Vacation Itineraries:  Father shall be sanctioned $500 per count of violating the agreement regarding Father being required to provide Mother an itinerary for any trip planned for the children for a total of (9) trips planned for a total of $4,500. This shall be paid to mother in full within 90 days of this order. Failure to do so will result in additional sanctions and penalties and will be remanded into custody to serve a 30 day sentence.
d.      2007 back child care expenses: $100 per week from June 15th – September 1st for a total of $1,000 plus 6% interest …… Must be paid within 60days.
e.       Medical/school/professionals:  Father shall immediately turn over any and all records pertaining to the children’s medical care, dental care, orthodontics, school records, and therapy records. Father shall have a suspended sentence of 60 days to comply with this order.  Father shall not attempt to interfere or hamper Mother’s efforts to access this information in any way.

18.  TAPING THE CHILDREN AND MOTHER:  Father shall cease and desist any taping of conversations between Mother and her children. Any tape recording to have been found, prior to Judge Menno’s order shall deemed unlawful and shall be forwarded to the District Attorney’s office for investigation and prosecution as afforded under the law.

19.  MOTHER’S PRIVATE INFORMATION: Mother has the right to safeguard her personal information. Father’s attempt to access or to access her personal and private information shall be deemed unlawful and shall be forwarded to the District Attorney’s Office. Father knew of should have known that Mother’s private personal IRA information was private. Evidence provided warrants and investigation in which Father used his securities license to access and change Mother’s investment accounts without authorization. Mother shall forward all information to the District Attorney’s Office for investigation into Father’s unlawful acts to her personal identity.

20.  PURGERY:  Father’s affidavit stating the DCF was going to take away the children anyway if the Court’s did not grant him emergency ex-parte custody.  The DCF case worker and evidence proves otherwise.  Father willfully manipulate and abused this court‘s discretions with the false statements given at the consequences of the welfare of his children. This is an egregious act and will not be tolerated. This will be forwarded to the District Attorney’s Office for prosecution.  This court will seek the highest of penalties for this crime.
                                                                       
Laura Bonetzky-Joseph
                                                                        By Her Attorney,
Dated:                                                             _________________________________________
                                                                        R. Christian Hauffler, Jr., BBO# 225860
                                                                        HAUFFLER ASSOCIATES
                                                                        22 Washington Street
                                                                        Norwell, MA 02061
                                                                        781-837-3800

Rationale for Judgement 2012



COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
Plymouth/Brockton, SS                                                                  PROBATE COURT
                                                                                          DOCKET NO.: 06D0566-DV1
**************************
LAURA BONETZKY-JOSEPH, Plaintiff
Vs
MARLON JOSEPH, Defendant
**************************
Rationale for Judgment

The Court find that it must consider all of the relevant facts as testified to, not only by the DCF caseworker, but by the testimony of the witnesses. The Court acknowledged to the parties, Your Honor  would take judicial notice and review all the pleadings.  The Court finds that the Mother, Laura Bonetzky-Joseph, unwillfully signed the custody agreement in October 2008 under duress and necessity due to threats and intimidations she received. She promptly filed for multiple motions to overturn that decision but her gateway to be heard was denied temporarily was removed.

There has never been a parenting plan designed for success. There are no allocations for birthdays, holidays, school events, family emergencies, or family vacations.

The Court acknowledges the numerous times Father has filed to terminate visitation and all contact between Mother and her children and despite Court orders and denials, Father makes up his own orders to abide by – failing to recognize the authority of this Honorable Court if is does not agree with him.

The Court acknowledges the numerous times Father has filed for mental health exam of Mother with his motions being denied. Mother has never been found to be unfit or a danger to her children.

Father’s proposed parenting plans were designed to get Mother to surrender to his control which even when she unwillingly agreed, Father found every excuse to not abide them. He manipulated the system to drag out his position at the expense of the children in question. 

The Court finds that based on the testimony and pleadings, the Father has systematically and unilaterally under minded any positive relationship between the children and their Mother. Father willingly and admittedly disregarded the orders of this court and will continue to do so. It essentially allows Father to determine and control all of Mother’s time with the children and controls over her personal life for which he legally has no interest.

The Court finds that Father voluntarily and without notice to Mother, his change in medical care for the children, schools, family vacations or trips, and/or changes in their therapy despite the agreement he, himself, coerced Mother to sign in October 2008 with the threat if she did not sign it, she would never see her children again. It was Mother who was active in the care for their daughter when she was diagnosed with an internal birth defect which will require close monitoring until she reaches the approximate age of twenty.  Father took no interest in her medical care and has no experience on what to do in an emergency in case something happens. Mother is trained and certified in CPR and First Aid and is a Registered Medical Assistant. Father’s actions are a willful contempt and in violation of the Court’s order and the spirit and intent of parental duties and fitness. 

The Court finds that Father voluntarily and willfully failed to provide Mother with half of the 2006 and 2007 tax returns as he signed and agreed in the Divorce decree as well as the added child support for child care expenses in the summer of 2007. Mother has NEVER seen a single penny from those returns or child care expenses. This is a willful contempt and in violation of the Court’s order and the spirit and intent of parental duties and fitness.
The Court finds that Father voluntarily and willfully ignored this Court’s warnings of failing to abide by Court Ordered visitation in June of 2010 and still defies any order by this Court. Father unilaterally curtailed and/or terminated any contact between the children and Mother and the Maternal side of their family. The Court acknowledges Mother’s attempts to buy her children a cell phone to better build an individual relationship with her children without Father’s constant interference. This is a willful contempt and in violation of the Court’s order and the spirit and intent of parental duties and fitness  

The Court takes judicial notice that there is an order appointing the Grandfather as the Court appointed supervisor. Despite the order, the Grandfather testified that he had repeated problems regarding visitation issues, lack of cooperation from the Father, and refusal to discuss with him directly any and all concerns regarding visitation as Father did with the previous supervisors. For this Court to give sole legal and physical custody of the children would for all intents and purposes, add insult to injury. Father did everything in his power to strip mother from any part of her children’s life.  Father made no serious effort to keep mother involved in the children’s lives and neglected their medical care. He is morally and legally required to do so with the respect to the orders of the Court and he did not.  Simply put, he kicked her when she was down, and continues to kick her. Although, she keeps getting back up for her children as that is all that matters to her.

The children have repeatedly expressed the need and want to be with their Mother via DCF, Mark Kaeys (previous supervisor), Court records, and the children’s previous therapist. Mother is requesting full legal and physical custody of the children. When the children were in her custody, Father was not denied access to his children like Father has done. Mother always kept father involved despite his refusal. Past actions are best indicators of future actions. Mother is seeking a detailed and clear parenting plan that Father can not use, abuse and manipulate to suit his personal agenda. This is just and fair way to allow these parents to be positive parents. It was in the best interest in the children when Mother has full legal and physical custody as it is now.

The Court is highly concerned that the Father feels superior to that of this Court and that he feels it is in the best interest of the children to brainwash them and have them believe their mother does not exist and that their Step-mother is their real mother they need to acknowledge with whom he thrusted her upon the children prior to their parent’s divorce. His actions overall have alientated the children from their Mother and destroyed her ability to be a positive role model during their formative years. The evidence of perjury, abuse, alienation, stalking, harassment, and fraud is substantial and uncontroverted. The Mother at the same time recognizes the long term affects of abuse and recognizes her children have become a statistic. However, Mother has been and continues to be determined to learn everything she can to help her children heal from the traumas they have suffered and be their pillar of strength and endurance. That includes reeducating herself and use efforts to remain and participate in the children’s lives.

The fact that Father is the Regional Vice President of a financial services firm providing investments, mortgages, and insurance plans for families and businesses with 62 employees, with money to purchase a home, driving a newer model Infiniti wants the Court to believe he is should qualify for Masshealth. With that many employees and with that kind of assets, why should the tax payer give him free insurance? This speaks volumes to the Court in Father’s skilled abilities to manipulate the system to get what he wants at all costs. It is unconscionable.

CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Even in difficult circumstances, the best interests of the child is usually served by the children maintaining a relationship with both parents; the Court’s obligation is to craft creative orders to accommodate visitation with the non-custodial parent. McCarthy v McCarthy, 21 MassApp. Ct. 924, 925 (1985).

In Yannas, the childnren’s lives derived a benefit from their mother’s improved circumstances. See Yannas v Frondistou-Yannas, 395 Mass. 704, 712, 481 N.E. 2d 1153, 1158 (1985)

As seen in Custody of Vaughn, 422 Mass 590 (1996) and in  Care and Protection of Lilith, 61 Mass App. Ct 132 (2004) “witnessing domestic violence is itself a "grievous" harm. Id. at 595
Also seen in Care and Protection of Lilith; 61 Mass App.Ct. 132; (2004) -  The application of Custody of Vaughn to care and protection proceedings. In Custody of Vaughn, 422 Mass. at 595, the court declared that "physical force within the family is both intolerable and too readily tolerated, and  a child who has been either the victim or the spectator of such abuse suffers a distinctly grievous kind of harm." The court emphasized that the "very frequency of domestic violence in disputes about child custody may have the effect of inuring courts to it." Id. at 599. The court, therefore, reversed a decision by a Probate Court judge to award custody to a "father who had committed acts of violence against the mother," id. at 596, because the judge had "failed to make detailed and comprehensive findings of fact on the issues of domestic violence and its effect upon the child as well as upon the father's parenting ability." Id. at 599, quoting from R.H. v. B.F., 39 Mass. App. Ct. 29 , 40 (1995). Domestic violence, the court declared, "is an issue too fundamental and frequently recurring to be dealt with only by implication." Custody of Vaughn, supra.

In the Opinion of the Justices to the Senate; 427 Mass. 1201, p. 1293, March 11, 1998., the interest is one of the "liberty" interests protected by art. 10 of the Massachusetts Declaration of Rights, and the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.  "the overriding principle in determining [the rights of a parent to custody] must be the best interest of the child." C.C. v. A.B., 406 Mass. 679 , 691 (1990). There is a growing national awareness that children who witness or experience domestic violence suffer deep and profound harms. See, e.g., Custody of Vaughn, 422 Mass. 590 , 599 (1996); Fields, The Impact of Spouse Abuse on Children and Its Relevance in Custody and Visitation Decisions in New York State, 3 Cornell J.L. & Pub. Pol'y 221, 222-234 (1994); Cahn, Civil Images of Battered Women: The Impact of Domestic Violence on Child Custody Decisions, 44 Vand. L. Rev. 1041, 1055-1058 (1991).

We turn directly to the challenged orders, examining them under the familiar rule that we will not reverse the orders of a probate judge in the areas of custody and support unless the judge's findings are clearly erroneous. Mass.R.Dom.Rel.P. 52(a) (1975) King v. King, 373 Mass. 37 , 40 (1977). Prindle v. Fisk, 2 Mass. App. Ct. 843 , 844 (1974). Clarke v. Clarke, 3 Mass. App. Ct. 736 , 737 (1975). Daigle v. Daigle, 5 Mass. App. Ct. 847 (1977).


[1] Commonwealth v. Garuti, 23 Mass. App. Ct. 561, 564, 504 N.E.2d 357, 359 (1987)
[1] Andrea Maalouf v Elie Saliba; 54 Mass App. Ct 547; 2001

As seen in Mitchell v. Mitchell, 62 Mass. App. Ct. 769 , 772-773 (2005), preserving fundamental human right to be protected from devastating impact of domestic violence is Common-wealth's public policy, as reflected in many statutes; Marjorie Sher v. Robert Desmond 70 Mass App. Ct. 270 (2007).

[1]In the Case of SCOTT C. PEDERSEN vs. JULIE KLARE; DOCKET No. 08-P-1327 (2009), the parent who interfered with visitation was found in contempt and sanctioned $5,000 plus an additional $200 per day sanction for each day not in compliance with court order plus legal fees.

[1] Hernandes v. Branciforte, 55 Mass. App. Ct 212 (202)
As far as Father’s visitation interference, see Custody of Brandon, MA Supreme Court 407 (1990), where the court ruled preventing the offending parent from "interfering with his personal liberty in any way."  Parental unfitness to provide for the welfare and best interests of a child under G. L. c. 210, § 3, must be proven by clear and convincing evidence.[1] “Subsidiary findings must be supported by a preponderance of the evidence, and those findings will not be disturbed unless clearly erroneous. Ibid. A finding is "clearly erroneous when there is no evidence to support it, or when, 'although there is evidence to support it, the reviewing court on the entire evidence is left with the definite and firm conviction that a mistake has been committed.” Custody of Eleanor, 414 Mass. 795, 799 (1993), quoting from Building Inspector of Lancaster v. Sanderson, 372 Mass. 157, 160 (1977).

The “real advantage” test, or less strict standard, is based on the “realization that after a divorce a child’s subsequent relationship with both parents can never be the same as before the divorce … [and] that the child’s quality of life and style of life are provided by the custodial parent.” Yannas v Frondistou-Yannas, 395 Mass. 704, 710, 481 N.E. 2d 1153, 1157-58 (1985) (quoting Cooper v Cooper, 99 N.J. 42, 53 (1984)). And although it is clear in divorce proceedings that “the best interest of the children always remain the paramount concern, ‘[b]ecause the best interests of a child are so interwoven with the well-being of the custodial parent, the determination of the child’s best interest requires that the interests of the custodial parent be taken into account” Id. (quoting Cooper v Cooper, 99 N.J. 42, 54 (1984)).

A Judge’s findings in a custody proceeding must be specific and detailed so as to demonstrate that close attention has been given to the evidence. Adoption of Warren, 44 Mass. App. Ct. 620, 625, (1998).
She testified that she was threatened by her previous attorney, Attorney Alessi who told her he would get a Guardian appointed against her if I did not sign it. She also testified that she fired her attorney the day before the trial when she learned her attorney had no intention of going to trial and told her he wasn’t going to “allow” her to go to trial.[2]  Commonwealth v. Garuti, 23 Mass. App. Ct. 561, 564, 504 N.E.2d 357, 359 (1987)

Father stated Mother attempted suicide and was unresponsive. He NEVER called 911  Commonwealth v Scott Vaughn; 43 Mass App. Ct. 818; 1997 – As seen with this case law, if true, then the defendant acted recklessly because his conduct "created a high degree of likelihood that substantial harm would result to the victim." with wanton and reckless conduct.

Finally Mother contends that the Judge Menno erred in granting permanent custody to the father under G. L. c. 119, § 26.[3] 

The rights of parties to custody are equal in the absence of misconduct and the welfasre and happiness of the children are determining criteria. MGL Ch. 208 Sec 28; 31 (1989) and Supp. 2001; Bouchard v Bouchard, 12 Mass. App. Ct. 899, 900 (1981).

The Judge saw and heard the witnesses and had the opportunity to evaluate their credibility. She was not obliged to believe contradictory evidence. Kaplan v Bessette, supra n. 13, at 234.

Judge’s assessment of the weight of evidence and the credibility of the witnesses is entitled to deference.  Custody of Eleanor, 414 Mass 795, 799 (1993).

Parents have no absolute or immutable right to associate with their children and their parental rights must yield to the best interests of the child. Donnelly v Donnelly, 4 Mass. App. Ct. 162, 164 (1976).

“The judge who has heard the testimony and seen the witnesses fact to face has a better opportunity for determining the credibility of their conflictin statement thatn can possibly arise from reading the record.” Custody of Eleanor, supra n.15, at 800 citing Spiegel v Beacon Participations, Inc, 297 Mass. 298, 407 (1937).

Rule 52A Notice
The Court reserves the right to make such additional findings of facts and rulings of law specifically as it relates to legal costs and expert fees pursuant to Mass, R. Dom. Rel. P. 52(a) in the event of a Notice of Appeal by either party.

The Court has entered a supplemental judgment consistent with these findings of facts and conclusions of law.

                                                                        Laura Bonetzky-Joseph
                                                                        By Her Attorney,
Dated:                                                             _________________________________________
                                                                        R. Christian Hauffler, Jr., BBO# 225860
                                                                        HAUFFLER ASSOCIATES
                                                                        22 Washington Street
                                                                        Norwell, MA 02061
                                                                        781-837-3800


[1] Case Law - Adoption of Rico; Docket 07-P-1883 (2008). Also see Adoption of Don, 435 Mass. 158, 164-165 (2001)
[2] See Commonwealth v. Garuti, 23 Mass. App. Ct. 561, 564, 504 N.E.2d 357, 359 (1987)
[3] Care and Protection of Lilith; 61 Mass App.Ct. 132; 2004 - Application of Custody of Vaughn to care and protection proceedings. In Custody of Vaughn, 422 Mass. at 595, the court declared that "physical force within the family is both intolerable and too readily tolerated, and . . . a child who has been either the victim or the spectator of such abuse suffers a distinctly grievous kind of harm." The court emphasized that the "very frequency of domestic violence in disputes about child custody may have the effect of inuring courts to it." Id. at 599. The court, therefore, reversed a decision by a Probate Court judge to award custody to a "father who had committed acts of violence against the mother," id. at 596, because the judge had "failed to make detailed and comprehensive findings of fact on the issues of domestic violence and its effect upon the child as well as upon the father's parenting ability." Id. at 599, quoting from R.H. v. B.F., 39 Mass. App. Ct. 29 , 40 (1995). Domestic violence, the court declared, "is an issue too fundamental and frequently recurring to be dealt with only by implication." Custody of Vaughn, supra.